17 infant wet towel evaluation: more convenient, more comfortable and safer wet towel to choose like this

Wet towels are the daily necessities of Baoma. Home or out of the house, rubbing their hands, feet, PP, toys … they can’t do without it.

How to choose a good and safe baby wet towel?

In this issue, stupid father chose 17 infant wipes with higher sales and brand awareness on the market. Comprehensive use of performance evaluation and material safety testing to provide you with some professional and objective wet towel purchase reference.

(P.S. If you don’t want to see the detailed evaluation process, you can pull it directly to the end of the text to see the general review. If you want to choose carefully, please read the full text patiently.)

Routine statement

: This baby wet towel was rated as a neutral position. The stupid father did not accept advertisements and sponsorship trying to affect the fairness of the evaluation results.

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

content

1. Evaluation sample & evaluation indicators

2. The first round of evaluation

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

BabyCare, Shunshun, Bi C, Little Raccoon, and Cotton Age, ranked among the top five.

3. The second round of evaluation

Three wet towels detect common preservatives, but the content is much lower than national standards.

4,

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

Comprehensive recommendation

Evaluation sample

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

Comprehensive factors such as sales of e -commerce platforms, brand awareness and price, this stupid father chose the following 17 baby wet towels as the evaluation object.

((

P.S.

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

Some brands have launched a number of infant wet towels of different series, so everyone should correspond to the name and packaging of the samples! )

▲ Sample map

Sample description:

1. The price of a single piece of a wet towel for 17 babies is between 0.05 yuan and 0.64 yuan. Among them, Yienbe is the cheapest and the most expensive.

2. Of the 17 baby wet towels, only Shunshun is 70 pieces/bag, and the specifications of the 16 models are 80 pieces/package.

Evaluation indicator

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

The first round of evaluation: use performance

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

① Packaging design ② area thickness ③ liquid content.

The second round of evaluation: security

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

Through the first round of evaluation, the stupid father will comprehensively evaluate 5 baby wet towels with better performance, and then conduct laboratory testing of the safety of its materials. The indicators include:

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

Fluorescent whitening agent, pH value, colorectal flora, pathogenic gyro bacteria, formaldehyde, 12 common preservatives (MIT/CIT/benzhenoxyl alcohol, etc.).

Finally, based on the results of the two rounds of evaluation, comprehensive recommendations are made.

Below, officially enters the evaluation session.

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

The first round of evaluation

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

Package Design

Evaluation method

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

: Simulation Mom’s daily drawing situation of wet towels, check whether the sealing/sealing stickers are easy to open and closed, and whether the wet towel is easy to extract.

Evaluation results:

summary:

① Pigeon, NUK, curious, the sealing of 3 wet towels is simple

Seal

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

design. The sealing stickers need to be slightly hard, and it is easier to bond.

The disadvantage of only sealing stickers is that once the sealing stickers are not obtained, the wet towel is easier to dry.

(Example: Pigeon)

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

② The sealing of the other 14 wet towels is

Sealing lid+sealing sticker

Design, sealing water effect is better than the design with only sealing stickers.

However, one more sealing design may also increase the difficulty of opening the packaging, especially when holding the baby and one -handed operation.

Among them, the sealing buckle of Vida, Wuyang, and Bi C is a bit tight, and it may occur or not flexibly open or closed.

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

(Example: Vida)

The second -layer sealing sticker in the era of Yienbe and the whole cotton era is sometimes not easy to tear.

(Example: Yienbe)

When the sealing lid is turned on with the thumb, the other fingers are pressed on the sealed cover and the distance from the thumb is closer. The lid will be easier to open ~)

③ Pigeon, good boy, NUK, curiosity, Shunshun, 5 wet towels are extracted

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

Pump

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

Essence The extraction is convenient and fast, but the wet towels that are brought out should be pushed back to the packaging.

Among them, the sealing diameter of Pigeon and good children is small, and it is not easy to stop back. In addition, plug back may cause pollution to the wet towels in the packaging.

(Example: Good boy)

④ The other 12 wet towels are

Unsatisfactory pumping

Design reduces the possibility of pollution. When drawing, find the “edge” exposed by the top wet towel, and pull out the wet towel quickly as soon as you drag it.

(Example: babycare)

But the actual situation is sometimes not so ideal, and the “side” of the wet towel at the top may not be exposed. Zichu, Yienbe, Wuyang, Veda, frog prince, Kangbei, and cotton era, all appeared in the test

or

Pull out multiple photos at a time

The situation of wet towels increases the difficulty of extraction.

(Example: Zichu)

Thickness

: Use tape measures and measure thickness to measure the length/width and thickness of the wet towel, measure each wet towel three times, and finally take the average value.

① The area of ​​Shun Shuner is the largest, and Yienbe is the smallest. BabyCare is the thickest and the thinnest.

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

② The thickness of the area of ​​Shunshun Er is the best performance, and large and thick wet towels are more convenient and practical. At the bottom of the scoring of Yienbe.

(Shunshun Er)

Liquid content

: Refer to the method in the national standard “GB/T 27728-2011 Wet Scarf”, operate and calculate the liquid content of various wet towels. The liquid content of the national standard requires the liquid content of wet towels ≥1.7 times.

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

① The liquid content of 17 infant wet towels conforms to China’s national standard.

② Wet towels with high liquid content are more comfortable and practical. Among them, Yienbe has the highest liquid content and the lowest Pigeon.

(Yienbe)

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

Touch

: Experience the feel, softness of the wet towel, the feeling of rubbing on the skin, etc.

① Yienbe, Wuyang, frog prince, October crystals, little raccoon, Bi C, slightly feel the touch

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

Smooth

Essence

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

② Good children, babycare, Kangbei, Shunshuner, Bi C, can find out the surface of the wet towel

Pattern

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

; Curious, the cotton era feels a bit

Astringent

Essence It may be related to the pattern design or process of the wet towel.

Anti -stretch

: Holders stretch the wet towel, check whether the wet towel is easily pulled, and compare the deformation of the front and rear wet towels.

① BabyCare, Vida, Quanmai era, Deyou, Little Raccoon, Bi C, in the tensile stretch test

Not to be broken

, Can withstand the normal tension of ordinary adults. Among them, babyCare performed better, and the degree of deformation after stretching was the least.

(BabyCare)

② The other 11 wet towels were pulled in half in the tensile stretch test. in,

curious

The performance was poor, and it was easy to be torn without hard work.

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

(curious)

Whether to get rid of

: Wipe the wet towel 100 times on a pillar body 100 times to observe whether the fiber surface of the wet towel surfaces, whether there are fiber residues on the surface of the pillar body.

① Pigeon, BabyCare, Yienbe, Curiosity, Vida, Wuyang, Deyou, Kangbei, after 100 frictions, the surface of the wet towels appears to varying degrees of fiber.

② After rubbing the other nine wet towels, there is no obvious change on the surface of the wet towel, which is better.

odor

: Pull out the wet towel from the packaging to smell it.

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

① Prince of Bi C, Frog Prince, October Crystal, and Yenbe, basically can’t smell it. The other 13 wet towels can smell the smell of faint plant fragrance, fruity, milk fragrance.

② From the composition table of 17 infant wet towels, there are 14 plants such as lignol, aloe alcohol, purslane, chamomile, licorice and other plants. A little natural fragrance.

③ Pay special attention to,

Deyou, NUK, Pigeon

Three wet towels added bacteriostatic essence, chlorolytic glycogenic acid salt, phenoxyr ethanol and other sterilized bacteriostatic ingredients (standard red), and did not marked specific content. This type of ingredients may stimulate the delicate skin of the baby. It is not recommended to use it frequently for infants and young children. The stupid father will also give it

Deduction

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

(De You)

The first round of evaluation summary

After the evaluation of the above 7 projects, the stupid father divided the weights to different evaluation indicators (see the chart below) according to the important degree of evaluation indicators, and a weighted average calculation was performed. The total score and ranking of the first round of the first round of infants wet towels are as follows:

BabyCare, Shunshun, Bi C, Little Raccoon, and Cotton Age, ranked among the top five in the first round of evaluation.

So, what is the safety of the top five materials? Stupid father conducted a second round of safety evaluation for these five wet towels.

The second round of evaluation

The second round of material safety assessment includes 6 items:

Fluorescent whitening agent, pH value, colorectal flora, pathogenic gyro bacteria, formaldehyde, and 12 common preservatives.

Fluorescent whitening agent

testing method

: Ultraviolet analyzers with two wavelengths of 254nm and 365nm are exposed to 5 wet towels to check whether there is a fluorescent response.

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

(P.S. fluorescence reactions do not mean that there must be migrant fluorescent whitening agents, and fluorescent whitening agents need to be determined. Without fluorescence reactions, it means that there is no fluorescent white agent.)

Test Results:

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

The picture below is a comparative diagram of fluorescent reactions with fluorescence and 5 infant wet towels with fluorescent white agents

Essence There are no fluorescent reactions in the five infant wet towels, and there are no fluorescent whitening agents.

PH value

: Use a high -precision pH tester to determine the pH value of 5 wet towel liquids.

The national standard “GB/T 27728-2011 Wet Scarf” stipulates that the pH value of the human body should be within 3.5 ~ 8.5 range.

The pH values ​​of the five infant wet towels are in line with China’s national standard.

Laboratory testing

In addition to fluorescent whitening agents and pH, third -party professional testing agencies have also tested the following projects:

E. coli, pathogenesis, formaldehyde, and 12 common preservatives.

Test results:

① The test results of E. coli and pathogenesis of 5 infant wet towels are:

not detected

② The formaldehyde test results of 5 infant wet towel are:

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

qualified

③ Shunshun Er and Bi C did not detect 12 common preservatives.

BabyCare and the little raccoon detected a common preservative, namely:

4-hydroxybenzoate ethyl, 4-hydroxybenzoate

In the cotton era, the above two preservatives were detected.

These two preservatives belong to Nepalese albums and preservatives, and excessive use may cause contact dermatitis. but,

The detection volume of BabyCare, Little Raccoon, and Cotton Age is much lower than the national standard limit, and security is no problem.

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

See the table below for specific situations.

Comprehensive recommendation: babyCare, Shunshun Er, Bi C

Comprehensive two -wheeled evaluation results, the final score and ranking of the five infant wet towels are as follows:

First place: babyCare

Reference price: 0.36 yuan/piece

Evaluation

: Sealing cover+sealing sticker design, non -continuous pumping, easy to extract, large and thick, 2.9 times the amount of liquid content, and the stretching performance is better. Although a common allergenic risk preservative is detected, the detection value is far lower than the national standard limit, and there is no problem with security.

Second place: Shunshun Er

Reference price: 0.64 yuan/piece

: Sealing cover+sealing sticker design, continuous pumping, easy to extract, the area and thickness of the thickness are excellent, 2.3 times the amount of liquid content, although the stretching performance is general, but there is no problem with daily wipes, the safety of the material is no problem. Common allergic preservatives.

Third place: Bi C

Reference price: 0.07 yuan/piece

: Sealing cover+sealing sticker design, non -continuous pumping, the area thickness ranks in the top five, 2.7 times the amount of liquid content, good tensile extension, no problem in material safety, affordable price, and high cost.

Special statement:

The detection samples are purchased randomly and independently, and the detection data of different batches of products may fluctuate. The test results are only responsible for the delivery of batch products, but the stupid father believes that the quality of responsible enterprise products should be as stable as possible.

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

Well, the evaluation of the baby wet towel in this issue is over. If you think the article is useful, and you are willing to support the stupid father for more product evaluation, please also forward more support!

If you want to inquire more related articles, or if you have any questions, you want to consult. Welcome to pay attention to the “Baby Evaluation” WeChat public account (ID: baObaoPingce) and leave a message in the background. The stupid father will answer it alone.

Recap history

1, 32 national bank version milk powder comprehensive evaluation

2, 38 domestic milk powder comprehensive evaluation

3. Five version of the Milk Powder of the Beauty Milk Powder Complete Evaluation

4. Mesujiaer 23 milk powder comprehensive evaluation

5. Mead Johnson 33 milk powder comprehensive evaluation

6. A2 milk powder comprehensive evaluation

7, 66 bottle & pacifiers evaluation

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

8. Baby sunscreen evaluation

9. Baby mosquito repellent product big evaluation

10, 22 baby rice noodles evaluation

11, 13 babies vitamin D evaluation

12, 20 primary pants evaluation

Please check in the historical article of the “Baby Evaluation” headline; or pay attention to the “Baby Evaluation” WeChat public account (ID: baObaopingce), and enter the corresponding keyword query in the background.

For “Baby Evaluation”, please click “Learn more” below. Welcome to reward the stupid father ~

Welcome to pay attention to “Baby Evaluation”. 7 years of commodity comparison testing experience, do not speculate, and use scientific and rational stupid methods to provide reliable consumer suggestions.

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

((

P.S.

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

Evaluation method

Evaluation method

Evaluation method

Evaluation method

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

Evaluation method

Evaluation method

Evaluation results:

Evaluation results:

Evaluation results:

Evaluation results:

Evaluation results:

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

Evaluation results:

summary:

summary:

summary:

summary:

summary:

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

summary:

Pump

Essence

Essence

Essence

Essence

Essence

Essence

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

testing method

17款婴儿湿巾测评:更方便更舒适更安全的湿巾要这样选

Test Results:

Evaluation

Evaluation